Sunday, December 16, 2018

Czech New Wave

“What's the difference between the Austrian constitution and the Czechoslovak constitution? They both secure freedom of speech, but only the Austrian one secures freedom after speech.” Czech joke, communist era

Much like the Czech people themselves, there is a black humour to the history of Czechoslovakian cinema from World War I to the start of the Czech New Wave. On the one hand, a strongly supported film industry with a great amount of investment from governments - unconcerned about making a profit. Some of the best equipped studios (e.g. Barrandov) and technology in Europe. On the other hand – no freedom in what films you make. (1)

The Czech film industry existed in a world of Nazi occupation* through Communism, Novotny’s presidential reign and then back to Communism again. This meant for the artists of these times a climate of repression and censorship.

And yet, history has shown us that artist’s will always find a way of dodging around the rules of censorship [link], of subverting rules to create a more impactful point (in this example, Hitchcock applied to the rule that kissing was not allowed for more than three seconds, creating an erotically charged scene.) Nowhere is this more true than in the films of the Czech New Wave.

The Czech New Wave came about during President Novotný term as President of Czechoslovakia and some years after the process of De-Stalinization. Novotný’s reign may have been a gradual softening of Communist doctrines but censorship was still very much in effect.

And for the people of Czechoslovakia – old communist problems remained. Food shortages, power failures, bribery and an inept bureaucracy created a growing frustration for a populace who had been promised a better, more humane face of Socialism. (2)  

The Czech New Wave was one arm of the eventual forces that led to the unfortunately brief Prague Spring. An artistic movement that attacked Novotný’s governance and avoided censorship through subversion, animation,  surrealist imagery and primarily black humour.


Nowhere is this more clear than in The Fireman’s Ball (Miloš Forman, 1967) – a film made towards the end of Novotný’s reign – that cleverly (and hilariously) cuts at the regime. The very first scene starts with a committee arranging a party for the leader (the retired chairman) who has cancer. But…he doesn’t know he has cancer. Everyone knows he has cancer but he doesn’t. The Doctor’s can’t tell him – it’s against the law. The conversation concludes with the logical ‘If he knows, he knows. And if he doesn’t know – we’re not going to tell him.’


It’s bizarre in that the logic of the conversation almost makes sense on a comedic level. Why tell a dying man he is dying? But on a subversive level we can read the Chairman as being Novotny or the ideology of the regime (or both). It is dying. Everyone knows this but no one can tell him. The Doctor’s – whose job it is to tell him are forbidden to tell him. And here – the Doctor’s could represent, on one hand, those in authority in a position to tell him. On the other, anyone in society aware of it’s ills (artists, musicians or even film-makers.) It is a scene both brilliantly hilarious and damning at the same time.

The film continues in this vein – with allegories for food shortages, enforced conscription (through contestants of a beauty parade), thievery (‘everyone steals while you just watch, you old fool’) and a bumbling, indecisive bureaucracy. And where the film really shines, beyond it’s comedic value, beyond it’s satirical sideswiping is that it treats the people within it not as idiots but as victim’s of human nature caught within a system that exacerbates problems rather than solve them.   

In one of several plans to ban the film, Novotny’s government had a test screening at the town where the film was based in the hope they would be furious at how they had been portrayed. A stooge of the government, planted in the audience to raise this point, was laughed out of hand. The audiences saw it for truth - ‘It’s exactly what happens here’ (3)

REFERENCES: 
(     (1) Stefan M. Piech (1997) The impact of the 1989 velvet revolution on the former Czechoslovakian film industry, Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 10:1, p.40

      (2)  Hartshorne, Kevin, Czechoslovakia - Two Years After, Australian Left Review, 1(26), 1970, 22-30.
      (3)   Kemp, Philip, Sight & Sound; September 2009, Vol. 19 Issue 9, p84-84, 1p

Is Horror Art?


In terms of artistic credibility how is the horror genre viewed? The term ‘elevated horror’ is a relatively recent term used to describe films that actually have artistic merit, a deeper meaning than most horror movies. However, ‘elevated’ is a descriptor unique to the Horror Genre. April Wolfe, film-critic wrote ‘I don’t say ‘elevated dramas’ to distinguish between the dramas I like and don’t like.’ By its very definition it tells us that horror – as a genre – struggles to have an artistic identity.

Get Out (Director: Jordan Peele, 2017), an example of 'elevated horror'.
And yet the Horror’s genre actual origins comes from cultured roots – that of the films of German Expressionism. Films such as The Student of Prague, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari and Nosferatu were and are considered to be of high artistic merit [LINK] and yet all are horror.  


The German Expressionism period covered the 1910’s to 1930’s. This movement was born from several strands of life in Germany at the time. Firstly, their deep roots of German folklore which gave them an innate understanding of the supernatural – or as Eisner puts it - ‘Myticism and magic, the dark forces to which Germans have always been willing to commit themselves’ (1).

Krampus - part of Germany's dark mythology
Secondly the deep turmoil of the German psyche at the time, beset as it was from the First World War, Spanish Flu and abject poverty – led to a population uncertain and anxious of the world around them – and alert to supernatural forces. 

This art movement informed the films created in the period and the low budget (compared to Hollywood productions) meant that creative solutions were sought. Set designs were often painted backdrops. The Cabinet Of Dr. Caligari used sets painted by expressionist painters Walter Röhrig and Walter Reimann to excellent effect – to display the twisted mind of narrator Francis. Germans also actively sought to make their films high culture – defined as Kulturnation.


These films were popular in Germany because it spoke to their deep-seated fears of the period. For example, Nosferatu showed a fear of foreign lands and highlighted a growing worry of sexual liberation of women within Germany. It also contains some troubling anti-Semitic imagery, part of a strained relationship that Europeans had with Jewish people and also (more likely) fuelled by Dolchstoßlegenden with the supernatural effect of Nosferatu literally draining the vitality from the town of ???.

(image nosferatu – rats) tag: Overt and troubling – the symbolic portrayal of Jews in Nosferatu. 

Internal fears, fears of ‘The Other’ is a primary reason for horror’s success as a genre. If you think of Invasion of the Body Snatchers (Communism), Night of The Living Dead (racism), The Wicker Man (decline of religion) you can see very real fears of periods and cultures being played out on screen.

That horror is popular is in no doubt [link] – but to return briefly to my original question, considering it’s artistic origins why does horror struggle to maintain an artistic validity today? One of the main points – to my mind – is that horror is a victim of it’s own fandom. Horror movies are cheap to make and will sell to a hungry market (with an unholy appetite?) regardless of quality. This in turn attracts exploitative producers who churn out run of the mill films based on gore, jump scares and with little to no meaning. This is something that Jordan Peele, writer and Director of Get Out understands:

‘Every great horror movie comes from a true fear, and ideally it's a universal fear.’

Friday, December 14, 2018

Hong Kong Horror

What’s the traditional way of combating a vampire? First thoughts might go to crucifixes, wooden stakes and garlic but what if I told you that the best way of defeating a vampire is with rice, mirrors and chicken eggs – at least in China. Not all traditions are the same and Chinese vampires – or Jiangshi - are corpses that travel by hopping with outstretched arms and - according to the Hong Kong movies of the 80’s - are excellent at martial arts.  



To the occidental viewer Hong Kong horror may not seem to have much in common with what we consider a horror movie to be. For a start there is a greater deal of physicality in Hong Kong horror – be it martial arts or slapstick comedy.(demonstrated here by legendary actor and director Sammo Hung). Where a western film might start with ‘life as normal’ to better emphasise whatever terror is to come.  The Hong Kong horror will normally be quick to introduce a fight scene. 

The central protagonist in a Hong Kong horror is different from what we expect as well. Normally not too bright, naïve, downtrodden and bumbling (responsible for some of the aforementioned slapstick), the protagonist will often stumble into danger. (in a Chinese Ghost Story, the main protagonist chooses an old and spooky temple to sleep in). These characters never seem to follow an emotional arc and it could be argued that for some movies the characters are the same from the beginning to the end.   

The exoticism and strangeness of Hong Kong horror movies are part of their appeal and nowhere is this more apparent than the supernatural / mythical  creatures that our protagonists must battle against and how they combat them. However, this is where Hong Kong horror and many Western horror’s share similarities – inspiration for stories is drawn from our own history of folklore and religion. Where our sources might be Christian, Hong Kong draws inspiration from Confucianism, Taoism and Buddhism as well as a very strong sense of folklore traditions.  
  
Hong Kong horror also shares a similar aesthetic to our horror movies. The use of blue, cold tones and ghostly mists would not seem out of place in A Nightmare on Elm Street or Poltergiest. And whilst in Hong Kong the protagonist might get more combatative with supernatural beings this doesn’t stop the Hong Kong Horror movie from pulling the horror staple of the jump scare at its audience. 

Wednesday, November 21, 2018

Hard Reset - Dogme '95


In the 1990’s, in Hollywood at least, the feature film was the home of the big budget extravaganza. Big name stars and ever evolving special effects became the prominent appeal to draw audiences in. Interesting plots, deep characters and truth in film became secondary concerns.

Jurassic Park - hugely successful cinematic spectacle   
On March 13th, 1995, director Lars Von Trier presented the Dogme ’95 manifesto at Le cinéma vers son deuxième siècle conference.  The purpose of the manifesto? A direct challenge against Hollywood, against technology and ego – and a search for truth in film versus the Hollywood ideal of illusion in film. To quote directly from the manifesto: ’The ‘supreme’ task of the decadent film-makers is to fool the audience. Is that what we are so proud of?’. Dogme ’95 aimed to dispel all artifice from film-making – and to be part of this movement meant following the rules.



The Vow of Chastity was a rescue action meant to save film from itself. If these rules seem punitive it’s because they are meant to be. On one level, we see time and time again how constraints serve to liberate the artist. Dogme '95 was a movement that voluntarily moved itself towards restraint. But from the point of view of Lars Von Trier these Vows were voluntarily made ‘to give away control’, to remove every bit of comfort and convention that the Director relies on - born from tradition and efficiency. 

And despite the restrictions, or maybe because of them, both the originators of Dogme ‘95 talked about its liberating experience as an artist. Thomas Vinterberg: ‘It was highly liberating that the responsibility of the film was lying in the rules and the brotherhood. It was all a game we were playing.’ 

  
We have seen [time] and [time] again how constraints serve to liberate the artist. The difference with Dogme is that here the artists created their own restrictions, and with it, created a series of films that created shockwaves across the world.  

Two of the initial films of Dogme - Festen and Idioterne were both critically acclaimed upon release. Although arguably the critical reaction to Idioterne was somewhat mixed.   
 What was clear from the reaction of both films, and the films that followed, was that Dogme films had created something new and controversial. The enfant terrible of the cinematic universe.   

It soon became a victim of it’s own success (something that Lars Von Trier had prophesiced in Idioterne, and after ten years of Dogme films it was agreed no more films would be certified as Dogme. In the words of Vinterberg ‘it became fashion. Dogme became a free ride to all festivals in the world and a recipe for success. When the risk is gone it’s no longer revolt.’