“What's the difference between the Austrian
constitution and the Czechoslovak constitution? They both secure freedom of
speech, but only the Austrian one secures freedom after speech.” Czech joke,
communist era
Much like the
Czech people themselves, there is a black humour to the history of
Czechoslovakian cinema from World War I to the start of the Czech New Wave. On
the one hand, a strongly supported film industry with a great amount of
investment from governments - unconcerned about making a profit. Some of the
best equipped studios (e.g. Barrandov) and technology in Europe. On the other
hand – no freedom in what films you
make. (1)
The Czech film
industry existed in a world of Nazi occupation* through Communism, Novotny’s presidential
reign and then back to Communism again. This meant for the artists of these
times a climate of repression and censorship.
And yet,
history has shown us that artist’s will always find a way of dodging around the
rules of censorship [link], of subverting
rules to create a more impactful point (in this example, Hitchcock
applied to the rule that kissing was not allowed for more than three seconds,
creating an erotically charged scene.) Nowhere is this more true than in the films
of the Czech New Wave.
The Czech New
Wave came about during President Novotný term as President of Czechoslovakia
and some years after the process of De-Stalinization.
Novotný’s reign may have been a gradual softening of Communist doctrines but
censorship was still very much in effect.
And for the
people of Czechoslovakia – old communist problems remained. Food shortages,
power failures, bribery and an inept bureaucracy created a growing frustration
for a populace who had been promised a better, more humane face of Socialism. (2)
The Czech New
Wave was one arm of the eventual forces that led to the unfortunately brief
Prague Spring. An artistic movement that attacked Novotný’s governance and
avoided censorship through subversion, animation, surrealist imagery and primarily black
humour.
Nowhere is this
more clear than in The Fireman’s Ball (Miloš Forman, 1967)
– a film made towards the end of Novotný’s reign – that cleverly (and
hilariously) cuts at the regime. The very first scene starts with a committee
arranging a party for the leader (the retired chairman) who has cancer. But…he
doesn’t know he has cancer. Everyone knows he has cancer but he doesn’t. The
Doctor’s can’t tell him – it’s against the law. The conversation concludes with
the logical ‘If he knows, he knows. And if he doesn’t know – we’re not going to
tell him.’

It’s bizarre in
that the logic of the conversation almost makes sense on a comedic level. Why
tell a dying man he is dying? But on a subversive level we can read the
Chairman as being Novotny or the ideology of the regime (or both). It is dying.
Everyone knows this but no one can tell him. The Doctor’s – whose job it is to
tell him are forbidden to tell him. And here – the Doctor’s could represent, on
one hand, those in authority in a position to tell him. On the other, anyone in
society aware of it’s ills (artists, musicians or even film-makers.) It is a
scene both brilliantly hilarious and damning at the same time.
The film continues
in this vein – with allegories for food shortages, enforced conscription
(through contestants of a beauty parade), thievery (‘everyone steals while you
just watch, you old fool’) and a bumbling, indecisive bureaucracy. And where
the film really shines, beyond it’s comedic value, beyond it’s satirical sideswiping is that it treats the
people within it not as idiots but as victim’s of human nature caught within a
system that exacerbates problems rather than solve them.
In one of
several plans to ban the film, Novotny’s government had a test screening at the
town where the film was based in the hope they would be furious at how they had
been portrayed. A stooge of the government, planted in the audience to raise
this point, was laughed out of hand. The audiences saw it for truth - ‘It’s
exactly what happens here’ (3)
REFERENCES:
( (1) Stefan M. Piech (1997) The impact of the 1989 velvet
revolution on the former Czechoslovakian film industry, Innovation: The
European Journal of Social Science Research, 10:1, p.40