Sunday, December 16, 2018

Is Horror Art?


In terms of artistic credibility how is the horror genre viewed? The term ‘elevated horror’ is a relatively recent term used to describe films that actually have artistic merit, a deeper meaning than most horror movies. However, ‘elevated’ is a descriptor unique to the Horror Genre. April Wolfe, film-critic wrote ‘I don’t say ‘elevated dramas’ to distinguish between the dramas I like and don’t like.’ By its very definition it tells us that horror – as a genre – struggles to have an artistic identity.

Get Out (Director: Jordan Peele, 2017), an example of 'elevated horror'.
And yet the Horror’s genre actual origins comes from cultured roots – that of the films of German Expressionism. Films such as The Student of Prague, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari and Nosferatu were and are considered to be of high artistic merit [LINK] and yet all are horror.  


The German Expressionism period covered the 1910’s to 1930’s. This movement was born from several strands of life in Germany at the time. Firstly, their deep roots of German folklore which gave them an innate understanding of the supernatural – or as Eisner puts it - ‘Myticism and magic, the dark forces to which Germans have always been willing to commit themselves’ (1).

Krampus - part of Germany's dark mythology
Secondly the deep turmoil of the German psyche at the time, beset as it was from the First World War, Spanish Flu and abject poverty – led to a population uncertain and anxious of the world around them – and alert to supernatural forces. 

This art movement informed the films created in the period and the low budget (compared to Hollywood productions) meant that creative solutions were sought. Set designs were often painted backdrops. The Cabinet Of Dr. Caligari used sets painted by expressionist painters Walter Röhrig and Walter Reimann to excellent effect – to display the twisted mind of narrator Francis. Germans also actively sought to make their films high culture – defined as Kulturnation.


These films were popular in Germany because it spoke to their deep-seated fears of the period. For example, Nosferatu showed a fear of foreign lands and highlighted a growing worry of sexual liberation of women within Germany. It also contains some troubling anti-Semitic imagery, part of a strained relationship that Europeans had with Jewish people and also (more likely) fuelled by Dolchstoßlegenden with the supernatural effect of Nosferatu literally draining the vitality from the town of ???.

(image nosferatu – rats) tag: Overt and troubling – the symbolic portrayal of Jews in Nosferatu. 

Internal fears, fears of ‘The Other’ is a primary reason for horror’s success as a genre. If you think of Invasion of the Body Snatchers (Communism), Night of The Living Dead (racism), The Wicker Man (decline of religion) you can see very real fears of periods and cultures being played out on screen.

That horror is popular is in no doubt [link] – but to return briefly to my original question, considering it’s artistic origins why does horror struggle to maintain an artistic validity today? One of the main points – to my mind – is that horror is a victim of it’s own fandom. Horror movies are cheap to make and will sell to a hungry market (with an unholy appetite?) regardless of quality. This in turn attracts exploitative producers who churn out run of the mill films based on gore, jump scares and with little to no meaning. This is something that Jordan Peele, writer and Director of Get Out understands:

‘Every great horror movie comes from a true fear, and ideally it's a universal fear.’

No comments:

Post a Comment